Subscribe to our RSS feed

Popular News Stories

  • Fuck poz guys!
  • Tom Hanks in Philadelphia Changed my Life
  • Canadian AIDS Society’s AGM and PHA Forum in Ottawa: some scholarships for HIVers available
  • Semen goes viral – or does it?

Smoking Cessation

Nov04

E-cigarettes

Tuesday, 04 November 2014 Categories // Current Affairs, Health, Smoking Cessation , Living with HIV, Opinion Pieces, Megan DePutter

Are they for harm reduction, a tool to help people quit or both? And what about the authorities’ attempts to regulate them? Megan DePutter weighs in on the vaping craze and the issues it raises.

E-cigarettes

Upon moving to Glasgows west end, I noticed a number of things about my neighbourhood: a striking abundance of lovely restaurants, cafes filled with appetizing sweets in the windows, cozy pubs, and more electronic cigarette shops than I could count. 

I dont want to comment on whether e-cigarettes are safe, because I cant pretend to truly know enough about them. However, when I look at some of the arguments against e-cigarettes, I do notice some trends that frequently pop up in harm-reduction/abstinence debates. 

For example, arguments against e-cigarettes often point to the concern that vaping does not act as an effective smoking cessation product. This is consistent with most discussions about other drugs, where there is an assumption that the goal is abstinence. 

The other argument against vaping is that e-cigarettes still contain nicotine - which is precisely why e-cigarettes could be considered a danger, or an effective harm reduction product.

It was recently announced that Nova Scotia is re-writing tobacco legislation to prevent people from using e-cigarettes indoors. Furthermore, they intend to ban stores from selling e-cigarettes to those under 19 and from displaying, advertising or promoting them.They also aim to ban the sale of flavoured tobacco.

What I found most interesting about this is how the Health Minister Leo Glavine justified the new legislation: "The flavour juice, it's still nicotine. It becomes an addiction for our youth and that's where we draw the line. 

Thats an interesting choice of words, I think, as he focuses on the fact that its an addiction, rather than the harmful effects of nicotine itself. 

I look at some of the claims that the e-cigarette shops advertise on their shop windows here in Glasgow and wonder if they are exaggerated. They make vaping sound less harmful than drinking tea.

The thought has crossed my mind that perhaps instead of quitting, smokers may simply switch to vapor. Then I realized this is the same argument that people make against harm reduction: that giving someone a clean needle will only encourage them to continue using. Is this why the government intends to control e-cigarettes? To keep the focus on abstinence instead of harm reduction? 

Now, I am a believer in the regulation of food and drugs (for example, it irks me to no end that the naturopathic community can peddle all sorts of products with lofty claims to fix everything from rheumatoid arthritis to cancer to HIV with no shred of clinical research or scientific evidence). It makes sense that this industry should have to abide by some regulation and make claims backed on scientific evidence. But everything Ive heard about cigarettes is that the tar and other chemicals they are loaded with are what truly generates the most risk. So even if e-cigarettes present a risk of nicotine addiction, arent they already a huge step ahead of traditional cigarettes, which contain 40 known carcinogens among the 10,000 chemicals?  I cant help but wonder whether the rush to control vaping is a reaction that is located somewhere in the harm reduction / abstinence debate. 

Arguments against vaping because of potential nicotine addiction could easily turned on their head, as people who find the smoking addiction tough to beat could at least significantly reduce the harms of smoking.

Usually the argument goes that nicotine is harder to beat than heroin or crack. Perhaps it is true; I know a lot of people who have beaten heroin or crack and continue to smoke cigarettes - it may very well be that smoking helps them manage their addiction throughout rehabilitation. Many probably consider smoking to be almost irrelevant after overcoming addictions to substances that threaten and impact their lives in a much more immediate way. 

Yet smoking is a big threat to health. I cant help to think of author Carolyn Knapp, who overcame alcoholism and a powerful eating disorder only to die of lung cancer. 

PositiveLite.com has reported a number of reasons why smoking is a significant concern for the health of people living with HIV (see related articles below) And so, in the HIV sector, supporting people in their cessation or reduction of smoking is probably one of the most important challenges today. If Im frank, I dont think the sector is doing enough to help smokers. Weve managed to get HIV drugs that can turn HIV into a chronic, manageable condition, and yet smoking threatens to jeopardize the health and longevity of people living with HIV, perhaps as much as anything else the sector is currently addressing. 

But it makes sense that a disproportionate number of people with HIV smoke. After all, smoking can be a coping mechanism to deal with stress, anxiety, or as I mentioned, manage other addictions. Nicotine can also stimulate attention and memory, and for people who are experiencing some of the neuro-cognitive effects of HIV drugs, it may make sense to reason that the stimulation that comes from nicotine is likely helpful. This is all to say that, given the difficulty in quitting smoking, and the reasons why people living with HIV smoke, wouldnt harm reduction be particularly advantageous, rather than pushing the age-old solution: just quit? 

Likely the increased regulations around vaping will be intended to prevent non-smokers from starting smoking, to prevent ex-smokers from starting again, and to encourage people who are on the path of smoking cessation to quit rather than take up vaping. But I fear that this approach will miss the mark of supporting people who are already smokers by offering them a chance to significantly reduce the harms of traditional cigarettes. As I mentioned, some regulations and limits are likely a good thing, but limiting the access to, and attractiveness of, vaping may do more damage than good, and only in the name of His Holiness, Abstinence.

Arts and Entertainment Section

Activism Section

Current Affairs Section

  • E-cigarettes

    E-cigarettes

    Are they for harm reduction, a tool to help people quit or both? And what about the authorities’ attempts to regulate them? Megan DePutter weighs in on the vaping craze and the issues it raises.
  • PrEP pops up on cruising sites

    PrEP pops up on cruising sites

    Marc-André LeBlanc says that PrEP is a hot topic in HIV prevention circles. There is more and more discussion about it in gay media, on social networks, and even in mass media. But is it even on the radar of the average gay man?
  • Canadian Treatment as Prevention advocate lauded by his peers

    Canadian Treatment as Prevention advocate lauded by his peers

    PositiveLite.com interviewee Dr. Julio Montaner has been nominated to the Canadian Medical Hall of Fame, a prestigious honour that recognizes the significant contributions and achievements by Dr. Montaner in the field of HIV/AIDS. Bob Leahy reports.

Events Section

  • A big, fun “Kiss Off” to HIV.

    A big, fun “Kiss Off” to HIV.

    Wayne Bristow has been busy with his local ASO (AIDS Service Organization) putting his photography and new video creation skills to work on a World AIDS Day/Month event.
  • What Canada can learn from Australia’s HIV response

    What Canada can learn from Australia’s HIV response

    CATIE ED says “Australia has done better than Canada in terms of the number of people living with HIV, the number of new HIV infections, and the number of people who are aware they are living with HIV”; calls Canada’s accountability model "pretty mushy"
  • The evolution of angst

    The evolution of angst

    From grass roots activism to professionalism – and government imposed restrictions on advocacy work. Bob Leahy at a conference which examined the changing political context within which our much evolved community-based response to HIV takes place

Features and Interviews Section

  • The chaser’s tale – part two

    The chaser’s tale – part two

    Bob Leahy in part two of a frank conversation with recently diagnosed Joseph Sinnott who deliberately exposed himself to HIV in search of the erotic and a sense of belonging. Here Joseph discusses the aftermath of the act which made him positive.
  • The Undetectables

    The Undetectables

    Bob Leahy interviews the folks at New York’s’ Housing Works about their innovative new campaign which uses a comic book narrative to explore with clients the benefits of achieving and maintaining an undetectable viral load
  • The chaser’s tale – part one

    The chaser’s tale – part one

    Bob Leahy in a frank conversation with recently diagnosed Joseph Sinnott who deliberately exposed himself to HIV in search of the erotic and a sense of belonging. In part one, Joseph gives us a glimpse of drug use, slamming and the world of bug chasers.

Health Section

  • The chaser’s tale – part two

    The chaser’s tale – part two

    Bob Leahy in part two of a frank conversation with recently diagnosed Joseph Sinnott who deliberately exposed himself to HIV in search of the erotic and a sense of belonging. Here Joseph discusses the aftermath of the act which made him positive.
  • The End of AIDS Is a cynical lie

    The End of AIDS Is a cynical lie

    From TheBody.com Mark S. King says "I am not going to be here for the cure. I am not going to see the end of AIDS. And neither will you."
  • A gay man of substance(s)

    A gay man of substance(s)

    Patrick Ettenes talks about his experiences with drugs. “I’m writing about this and trying to be honest. When was the last time you looked in the mirror and did the same?”

International Section

Legal Section

Lifestyle Section

  • Second time around

    Second time around

    PositiveLite.com writer David Phillips is getting married today (Congratulations David and Craig!). Here are his thoughts.
  • A gay man of substance(s)

    A gay man of substance(s)

    Patrick Ettenes talks about his experiences with drugs. “I’m writing about this and trying to be honest. When was the last time you looked in the mirror and did the same?”
  • Poz Cruise 2014

    Poz Cruise 2014

    Joshua Middleton on the latest shipboard retreat filled with close to 300 men and women, both gay and straight, who are either living with HIV or affected by it

Living with HIV Section

Media Section

Opinion Pieces Section

Population Specific Section

Sex and Sexuality Section

MarketPlace